Primary Menu
BEVERLY HILLS, CA - AUGUST 02: (L-R) Documentary subjects Kate and Sabrina and Executive Producers Eric Evangelista and Shannon Evangelista speak at the 'Breaking Amish' discussion panel during the Discovery Networks/TLC portion of the 2012 Summer Television Critics Association tour at the Beverly Hilton Hotel on August 2, 2012 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images)

November 18, 2018 UPDATE:
The show returns to TLC tonight for another season. But most of the cast said “no thanks” when asked to return. Here’s who will be back and who won’t!



Original article from December, 2017
A friend of mine and I were just talking about how we want Santa to bring us another season of Return To Amish. I’m not proud to say that. It’s a meaningless show that has no redeeming qualities. It’s reality TV at its cheesiest. But if you were hooked too, wait til you hear what happened to the cast after cameras stopped rolling earlier this year.

Jeremiah and Carmela didn’t work out after all according to Starcasm. Things got rocky as the show was wrapping up. Police were called to their home. There were reports of domestic violence. She ended up leaving Jeremiah and went back to Washington, taking $15,000 and the kids. Jeremiah’s financial picture isn’t so great. The site reports he started a GoFundMe page. He says he can’t get a job because he has no transportation and that “haters” would show up at his workplace. In a YouTube video posted this week, Jeremiah says he and Carmela are working on their relationship.

Sabrina, the troubled mom who was trying to stay off drugs, ended up going to jail. She’s out now but her kids were adopted by a family member of the father.

Kate’s modeling career seems to be going well.

As for Abe and Rebecca, Starcasm says they’re not interested in another season of the show and have kept a low profile.

Hey it’s Geno. Here are my most recent posts. I’m big Lightning fan and Tampa Bay’s junk foodie. I grew up in Westbrook, Maine but Florida will always be home. Hook up with me on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. And catch Nights with Geno weeknights at 7 on 99.5 QYK!

Hey it's Geno. Thanks for reading. Got something to add to this story? Connect with me on Facebook, Instagram or Twitter.